Help Me Reach 12 on the Manly Scale of Absolute Gender

If you like the patriotic work we're doing, please consider donating a few dollars. We could use it. (if asked for my email, use "")

Friday, August 28, 2009

Department of Book Reports: The Defining Moment

Jonathan Alter has penned a fine biography and history of Franklin Delano Roosevelt's first 100 days as President in The Defining Moment (Simon and Schuster $16.00). Alter is a frequent guest, of course, on MSNBC's Countdown, and, yeah, I know, he's become something of a wanker on the public option. (He supports it, but is not sure if it is necessary for the Health Care bill that finally emerges out of Congress.) Nevertheless, this history is well-written and parallels much of what we are now going through.

But it was worse then. Banks were dying, unemployment was much higher and the temper of the country much uglier. FDR emerged as the candidate at a rather ugly convention (where, at that time, a candidate needed a 2/3 delegate majority), facing opposition from the 1928 Democratic standard-bearer, Al Smith, and Texas congressman, John Nance Garner. In a campaign where polling was in its infancy, and where the candidate was essentially wheel-chair bound, Roosevelt scored a huge victory over the incumbent Herbert Hoover. During this time, FDR was able to put together his "Brain Trust", and then his formidible cabinet, that included Henry Wallace, Frances Perkins and Harold Ickes among others.

Alter cites Roosevelt's flexibility for much of his success. Even as the transition from the previous administration was taking place, things seemed dire. As March 4th (the then Inaugural day) approached, there was a nationwide run on the banks. Panic was in the air. Many powerful men and pundits encouraged a benign dictatorship. Walter Lippman pushed FDR to that end. William Randolph Hearst was even more persistent. Hearst produced a film, "Gabriel Over the White House" that starred Walter Huston as President Hammond, who in order to implement his agenda, fires his cabinet of party hacks, and declares martial law and dissolves the Congress, and executes his enemies in front of the Statue of Liberty. One of FDR's triumphs was to resist this kind of temptation, and not dispense with that pesky democracy stuff.

The Defining Moment is available at Jackson Street Books and other fine independent bookstores.

And now a scene from one of my favorite movies, and certainly one of the finest to come out of the Depression, The Petrified Forest, based on the play by Robert Sherwood:

demo, can you spare a dime?


  1. SeattleDan:

    I can spare the dime, but first I'll need a check for $17,392.45 so's I can FedEx the money to you.

    Wow, Bette Davis and Lesley Howard looking like they were still doing high school plays. Rumor has it that Miss Davis was a genuinely delightful person.

  2. Re the youtube clip: where were the explosions? the shootings? the mayhem? Nice haircut on Bogie, though...


  3. Two huge mistakes:

    First, the public option is the only actual reform in the bill. Without it, the bill is essentially a windfall for the carriers. I'm in a household with a major illness. Query a world without private insurance or crap like we have: All the saved premiums and realistic fees: Are we really saving money with our coverage? In our case, you're talking about thirty years of premiums. If it all went into savings or conservative investments, would we have been better off than what we have? (Yes, Obama's epic failure with this has turned me into something of a Rockefeller Republican.)

    Second, there's a teeny difference between Obama and FDR. Obama is working hard to bring back the speculation bubble and avoid any reform of the financial sector. In seven months, there's been no substantive correction or "reform" of the corrupted system that got us here. Suffice to say, FDR was the opposite. Obama doesn't even rise to the level of Herbert Hoover, that's how reform-oriented he is. When the reality hits that we're perfectly on track for a W-shaped recession. And a Republican president elected in 2012, you, too, will say Thank you, Barack Obama. Just what we need: A Mix of Bill Clinton and Jimmy Carter.

  4. The Seditionist:

    Thank you for your input. It's always refreshing to hear a concern troll's perspective on why the demoncrats will fail once again. It has so little to do with the obstructionist tactics of the GOP.


We'll try dumping haloscan and see how it works.